Looking for a comfortable and affordable all-foam mattress? Great! You have come to the right place. Today we are comparing two great 10” all-foam mattresses, the original Puffy and Nolah mattresses. Both of these beds benefit from quality upgraded memory foams that not only help with pressure relief but with sleeping cool as well. While these beds may seem very similar, they actually have a few differences that may have you choosing one over the other. Keep reading our Puffy vs Nolah mattress comparison review to get all of the details. We are here to help you decide between these two great memory foam mattresses.
Puffy Mattress Highlights
- 10” – 3 Layers of Foam
- Medium-Firm Feel
- Memory Foam Feel
- Made in USA
- Sleeps Cool & Dry
- Solid Edge Support
- Trial Period: 101 Nights
- Warranty: Lifetime Warranty
- Price: $795 – $1350
- Puffy Mattress Review
The original 10” Puffy mattress may only have 3 layers, yet it’s simple design packs a punch when it comes to overall comfort and durability. This is a great mattress that relies on high quality materials to provide premium comfort over a complicated design.
Nolah Mattress Highlights
- 10” – 3 Layers of Foam
- Great Pressure Relief
- True Medium Feel
- Great for Side Sleepers
- Memory Foam Feel
- Designed in Denver CO
- Made in USA
- Wildlife Adoptions
- Trial Period: 120 Nights
- Warranty: Lifetime Warranty
- Price: $619 – $1119
- Nolah Mattress Review
The 10” model from Nolah is a great mattress to compare to the original Puffy mattress. Both featuring a 3 foam layer design with upgraded memory foams and cooling infusions. The Nolah mattress is not as well known as a brand as Puffy, but they have a lot in common. This Colorado based mattress company makes a darn good mattress at such an affordable price is a definitely a mattress to keep your eye on. Check out our At A Glance section below where we compare the Nolah and Puffy mattress side by side and pick a mattress as our choice for best buy.
Puffy vs Nolah – At A Glance
- Quality Materials: Tie
- Motion Transfer: Tie
- Edge Support: Puffy
- Side Sleeping Comfort: Nolah
- All Around Comfort: Puffy
- Sleeping Cool: Puffy
- Value: Tie
- OVERALL: PUFFY!
When looking at these two mattresses they honestly have a lot in common. One main feature that gives the Puffy an overall advantage is that it has a slightly firmer feel than the Nolah mattress. Making it closer to a Medium-Firm feel than a softer Medium comfort feel. This allows the Puffy to be a more universally comfortable bed. While it also gives a slight advantage for sleeping cool and edge support as well. Keep reading to get more details below.
Nolah vs Puffy – Delivery & Set Up
A huge benefit you get from buying either a Nolah or Puffy mattress is that they are both made right here in the USA, using many American made materials as well. Which is a huge benefit when it comes to the delivery and unboxing experience.
For one, it tends to get to you faster than a mattress built overseas, while the Puffy and Nolah mattress also have a lot less “new mattress smell”. While other mattresses are kept in their boxes while being shipped overseas and then stored for an extended period of time until you place your order. Instead Nolah and Puffy make their mattresses to order and then they ship from their American based factories.
Nolah and Puffy also use higher quality materials than most. All of their foams are CertiPUR US certified which means any scent your new mattress does give off, you can rest assured that it is not unsafe to have in your home.
When you order your new mattress, your bed will ship to your home in about one week or so. Then you will be able to take the compact box to your room of choice where you can then unbox and watch it come to life. We highly suggest leaving your mattress to firm up and air out in a well-ventilated room for at least several hours before use. This will help allow the mattress to reach it’s true firmness level as well as get rid of any potential lingering packaging smell.
Comfort – Puffy vs Nolah
The comfort of these two mattresses is really one of the biggest differences between the Puffy and Nolah mattress. The Nolah mattress is a bit softer coming in around a 5 – 5.5 on our firmness scale of 1 (super soft) – 10 (extra firm). Making the Nolah a Medium firmness level overall. With it’s memory foam comfort layers we found that is has great pressure relief and will work best for side sleepers.
While the Puffy mattress comes in around a 6 – 7 firmness level. This makes the mattress more of a Medium-Firm comfort level. Which is really our sweet spot that has the most universal comfort. By this we mean that almost all sleeping positions will find this level of firmness to be comfortable. Whether you like to sleep on your back, stomach, side, or a bit of all of them. You will likely be able to get some comfortable sleep on the Puffy’s Medium-Firm mattress.
Mattress Construction & Materials
Puffy – Materials:
As we mentioned previously, the Puffy mattress has a rather simple design consisting of only three foam layers. We will work our way up from the top to the bottom to see how it is built.
The base from in the Puffy mattress is made of their Firm Core Support Foam, this is a dense thick layer of foam that provides the majority of the bulk of the mattress as well and lots of support. This is a great foundation for the rest of the mattress.
The middle layer if made from Puffy’s ClimateComfort Foam. This has a cooling gel that helps keep the mattress cool from the inside out. It also serves as a transitional layer between the top comfort layer and the base foam.
Finally there is a the top layer of foam which is the famous Cooling Cloud Foam, that has the extra cooling gel infusion. This adaptive memory foam conforms nicely to your body while not letting you sink too far into the bed.
To wrap it all together is Puffy’s cover. This Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified fabric is made to zip off and wash easily. It is also stain resistant and breathable. Which is just about everything you could possible want out of a mattress cover.
Ready to sleep on your cloud? Shop the Puffy mattress and get the latest pricing at Puffy.com.
Nolah – Materials:
Similar to the Puffy mattress, Nolah has 3 different foam layers. The base foam is a 7 inch layer of their High-Density foam. This is a US made breathable base foam that helps support the other comfort layers.
Next up is their transitional layer of foam. They use what they call a Deep Supportive High-Resilience Foam for this layer. This is 1 inch of durable latex. This makes the Nolah a more responsive feeling foam mattress. Which keeps your from feeling stuck or too stuck in the mattress.
Their top layer of foam is the Cooling Nolah AirFoam. This is 2 inches of pressure relieving breathable memory foam. This is a higher quality memory foam that resists holding onto heat better than old school memory foams. Next up is the Nolah mattress cover. They made their cover out of a natural viscose material. While it is not stain resistant or washable like the Puffy cover, it is moisture wicking cool and oh so soft.
Interested in the balanced feel of the Nolah? Shop and get the latest pricing at Nolahmattress.com
All-Foam mattresses are the best at eliminating motion transfer in a bed. The Puffy and Nolah mattress are no exception to this general rule of thumb. The Nolah we found to be especially good at eliminating motion throughout a bed.
This is mainly due to it’s slightly softer feel and memory foam comfort layer. These are both motion eliminating features that will help cut down on nearly all motion and vibration throughout the bed.
We do believe Nolah has a slight advantage over the Puffy mattress when it comes to motion transfer. However, both the Nolah and Puffy are excellent choices for anyone looking for a mattress that does a great job at limiting the amount of movement that goes through the mattress.
Sleeping Cool – Puffy vs Nolah
When you are wanting to have a mattress that sleeps cool it is all about how a mattress handles heat. By that we mean that your body will always produce and let off heat into your mattress, so how it handles and removes that heat is how you know a mattress will sleep cool.
Hybrid mattresses rely a lot on their coil systems because it is such a great amount of airflow that gives heat a lot of space to escape from the mattress. All-foam mattresses used to be notoriously hot to sleep in. That is until brand like Nolah and Puffy realized that by using high end foams with different infusions can make a big difference in limiting the amount of heat retention within a bed.
Nolah uses their Airfoam on the top layer of the mattress to get as much airflow as possible near the body. This helps to keep heat from building up in the bed. This is also why they use an extra breathable fabric in their bed. This does a pretty good job at remaining temperature neutral throughout the night.
Although we did find that the Puffy mattress slept a bit cooler. This is partially due to the fact that it has a firmer feel. Since you sleep more on top of the mattress than sinking into the Puffy bed, this allows for a lot more airflow around your body. This is very helpful when it comes to sleeping cool. Puffy also has multiple layers with different gel infusions into their foam. This gives you multiple layers of defense against heat retention and we found that it works rather well. Which is why we choose Puffy as the overall winner for sleeping cool.
Edge Support – Puffy Mattress vs Nolah
If we are looking at this Puffy vs Nolah, we are going to give the win to Puffy for edge support. While all-foam mattresses tend to struggle with edge support due to their lack of durable coil systems, we found that the Puffy manages to provide a rather solid amount of edge support. You can lay down on the top of the Puffy mattress right up to the edge and feel very little difference in support. While you will notice more dipping when sitting on the side of the mattress, we think it manages to do a great job especially for an all foam mattress.
The Nolah also does a pretty good job at edge support as well. It is rather similar to the Puffy in that you won’t feel much difference in support when you lay close to the edge of the mattress. However, you will again feel less support when sitting on the edge of the bed. It is really the higher firmness level of the Puffy mattress that gives it the upper hand with edge support. The slightly firmer feel makes the Puffy just that little bit more supportive around the edges overall.
Between the Puffy and Nolah mattress we honestly feel that these prices are dead on with their quality and feel. While the Puffy mattress costs just a bit more than the Nolah mattress, we like it a bit more as well. Making the prices seem very in line with our preference level for each bed. Keep in mind the following prices do not reflect current deal OR our mattress coupons. So be sure to click the buttons below to get the latest and greatest deals!
Puffy Prices (BEFORE Coupons!)
- Twin: $795
- Twin XL: $825
- Full: $995
- Queen: $1,150
- King: $1,350
- California King: $1,350
Interested in the Puffy mattress? Learn more & Shop at Puffy.com
Nolah Prices (BEFORE Coupons!)
- Twin: $619
- Twin XL: $759
- Full: $879
- Queen: $1019
- King: $1119
- California King: $1119
Interested in the Nolah mattress? Learn more & Shop at Nolahmattress.com
Puffy vs Nolah Mattress Comparison Review – Overall:
What a great mattress comparison review to do. These two mattresses are such close competition to each other. 10” mattresses with 3 layers of foam that are both made in the USA? That also come in right around the same price range?! At that point how can you choose between the two? Well we will tell you. The comfort level is truly the biggest difference between the Nolah and Puffy mattress. It is also what effects the other features of the mattress like edge support and sleeping cool.
The Puffy is a medium-firm which works for most sleeping positions because it falls in that sweet spot. Since it is firmer than the Nolah it also sleeps cooler and a bit more edge support.
While the Nolah is closer to a Medium firmness level which is a bit softer and has more pressure relief. This is great for anyone who is a side sleeper who wants a little more contouring around their hips and shoulders. Which is really going to be how we would suggest picking between these two beds.
That’s Not All!
For more comparisons reviews make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This will give you access to all of our comparison reviews. Including Puffy vs Purple, Puffy vs Capser, Puffy vs Leesa and Nolah vs Casper. Also check out our Mattress Comparison Tool too for a really quick side by side glance at up to four of any of our mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.
Not sure where to start? No problem! Let us help you start your mattress search with Our Mattress Guide to take out any confusion.