Please note, we are proudly supported by our readers. The product links are referral based and if you purchase an item we make a small commission. For more information please see our disclosure page.
Today we are comparing two familiar all foam bed-in-a-box mattresses, the Purple vs Cocoon by Sealy. These two beds both feature solid all-foam bases. The Cocoon mattress has a memory foam comfort layer on top, while the Purple mattress is of course topped with their signature polymer grid. These two well-known and loved beds share a few strengths, however even with their similar designs the overall comfort to these beds are rather different. Keep reading to get all of the details and find out which bed we choose to be the Best Buy in this comparison review.
Purple has done something many other mattress companies have not, they managed to come up with something brand new, their Purple Polymer Grid. This is what they use to give their mattress loads of pressure relief that also stays much cooler than other materials like memory foam.
Although with anything that comes out that is new and different, there are going to be mixed reactions. Some people are not huge fans of the way the poly-grid feels while others are cult fans. Keep reading to learn more about it’s benefits and potential disadvantages to getting the purple mattress with its fancy grid comfort layer, and better determine whether or not it is the mattress for you.
While the Cocoon Chill has slightly less of a cult following as the Purple mattress has, it also tends to have more of a familiar memory foam mattress feel that many people already know and love. Memory foam has a way of conforming to the body and limiting motion transfer like no other material does.
If you are looking for that signature memory foam feel, not many other materials will give you that exact feel you’re looking for, and boy does the Cocoon mattress have plenty of that pressure relieving memory foam. Read the full article for all of our mattress comparison details of Purple vs Cocoon, or simply check out our following At A Glance comparison to get the gist.
There are so many different pros and cons to these two mattresses! Be sure to keep reading in order to get all of the details on the Purple and Cocoon mattress in order to better determine which is the mattress for you. Want to go with our winner, Cocoon? Make sure to take advantage of our 25% OFF mattress coupon with code: OSG25, to save even more on your Cocoon by Sealy mattress today.
Some mattress brands have very different delivery options; however, the Purple and Cocoon mattress are rather similar as far as ordering and delivering. When you order either of these beds your bed will than be shipped out to your home within around a week or two. Your new mattress will be vacuum packed and compacted into a relatively small box, that you will need to move to the room of your choice. We suggest having at least two sets of hands to move your new mattress as it will be compact yet rather heavy.
Once you have moved your mattress into the bedroom, you can slide it out of the box and safely remove from it’s vacuum packaging. Then you will have to pleasure of watching your new bed come to life. This is where we like to mention the “new mattress smell”
Any bed that is vacuum packed in plastic is going to give off a bit of a smell when it is released from it’s packaging and airing out. We find that depending on where the mattress was made, and what materials were used in the making of the mattress will have a big effect the intensity of said new mattress scent.
Overall the Cocoon mattress was not too intense as far as new bed smell. This is likely due to the fact that it is manufactured in the US, meaning it spends less time on average in it’s packaging. While Sealy also uses all CertiPUR-US certified foams to create their mattress. This means any smell that is coming out of your new bed will not be noxious in anyway. Which is great news.
Ready to order your new Cocoon mattress? Shop and learn more at CocoonbySealy.com.
While we noticed that the Purple mattress did have more of a scent overall when it came to unpacking. We believe this is mostly due to the fact that the Hyper-Elastic Purple Polymer Grid has a scent. The grid is also coated in a polyethylene copolymer powder coating, which is non-toxic but also has a bit of a scent. We have no reason to believe that these materials are harmful in anyway as even their foams are certified by CertiPUR-US as safe. Although we still suggest with all new mattresses ordered onto to allow them to breath and firm up in a well-ventilated room for several hours before use.
Try the “egg challenge” yourself when you order your new Purple mattress from Purple.com.
Purple made their original mattress 9.5” tall. It has a base of two foam layers that are topped with two inches of their Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid. While this is a very simple design, it is also incredibly effective in several ways for comfort, which we will get into further detail with later. However, while the Purple mattress is made famous by their polymer grid, it is not the only materials making up the Purple bed.
The original Purple mattress starts with a 4” base layer of foam. This is what gives the Purple mattress it’s foundation and supports the following two layers. The transitional layer of foam in the Purple bed is a 3.5” layer of a polyurethane foam. (The same type of material that memory foam is made out of). This foam layer helps to keep the layers from bottoming out onto the base layer of foam.
On top of the middle layer of foam is a 2” layer of the Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid, which finishes out the bulk of the mattress. This polymer is what makes the Purple mattress so cool to sleep on and provides the majority of pressure relief in the bed.
Last but not least there is the Purple mattress cover. This cover is called their SoftFlex cover because it has plenty of stretch allowing the grid to really do its magic. The SoftFlex cover is made out of a 29% Viscose, 67% Polyester, 4% Lycra blend. It is a stretchy soft material that tops the Purple mattress rather well.
Ready to try out the infamous purple grid for yourself? Get the best pricing at Purple.com.
Sealy’s design for the Cocoon mattress is a rather simple one. It consists of three foam layers topped with a soft textured cover. When you come across such a simple mattress design it is really the quality of the materials that will determine whether or not this will be a comfortable mattress, and the Sealy brand has been around long enough to know what materials to use in a mattress.
The base layer of the bed starts out with a 6” layer of a dense supportive foam, which gives the Cocoon mattress the majority of it’s support overall. This layer creates a solid foundation for the rest of the layers to work off of. Next up is the transitional layer of foam. This is a 2” layer of a softer foam that provides what Sealy calls deep pressure relief. This is when your body really pushes into the mattress it keeps you from sinking too far and hitting the base foam.
The final layer of foam is made out of Cocoon’s memory foam. This memory foam is oh so good and conforming to the contours of your body. It is full of pressure relieving properties and helps prevent uncomfortable aches and pains.
Then there is the cover for the Cocoon Chill mattress. This is what brings the Chill to the Cocoon mattress, which is the chill mattress cover. The fabric used in this cover feature phase change technology which actually feels cool to the touch. It is a great fabric that really helps to combat heat retention.
Which firmness is best for me? Find out below in with our firmness chart as well as recommended feels for your sleeping style.
We found that the Purple mattress came out to be around a 5-6 on our comfort scale where 1 is extra soft and 10 is extra firm. Making the Purple mattress around a Medium to Medium-Firm on the comfort scale. Which does fall right in line with what will be comfortable for most sleepers.
However, we do want to note that the Purple does feel and react differently. When you lay down on a purple mattress, you will be able to feel the texture of their Purple Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid. This will feel very different than just about any other mattress you have tried before. While it does great things for pressure relief and sleeping cool, it can take some getting used to.
We also found that the Purple Grid does not always stand up to excessive weight all that well. If you like the idea of the Purple grid but you need more support, then you may want to look into their hybrid versions, Purple 2, Purple 3, or even their most advanced/supportive Purple 4.
The Cocoon mattress by Sealy manages to be rather comfortable for having such a simple design and low price point. Cocoon comes in two different comfort options the Cocoon Medium-Soft and Cocoon Extra-Firm. Their Medium-Soft option was around a 4-5.5 on the comfort scale depending on how heavy you are and what you are used to, the mattress may seem more soft or firm. While the Extra-Firm comfort option came in closer to an 8.5.
If you are not sure what comfort level you would typically go for, we suggest matching it to the sleeping position you prefer most. If you are a stomach sleeper, you will likely prefer the firm option, while a side sleeper will prefer to softer option. If you are a back sleeper it is typically up to personal preference, although we prefer a medium-firm 5-6 feel for the average back sleeper is best.
Motion transfer is a feature this isn’t always a must have for everyone, although for those who share their bed it is often high on the list. All-Foam mattresses are a great option to go for with anyone who is looking to have as little motion transfer as possible in a mattress. Overall Purple does a rather great job at eliminating the majority of vibrations and motion throughout the bed. Although, we did find that there was a bit of motion that can be detected as the Hyper-Elastic Polymer Grid does have the slightest bit of bounce to it.
Cocoon is our overall winner in the Purple vs Cocoon review for Motion Transfer. What makes the Cocoon mattress so fabulous at eliminating motion throughout a mattress? It is mostly due to it’s all-foam design that is topped with a lovely memory foam. Memory Foam is the elite when it comes to getting rid of movement throughout a mattress. This is especially true with the softer comfort option. If you want to sleep straight through the night even if you have a sleeping partner who is tossing and turning, then this is a great mattress option for you.
Whenever you are looking for a mattress that sleeps cool, find the airflow. Wherever there is air flowing through a mattress, there is heat finding a way to escape. This is why we typically suggest hybrid mattresses for anyone who is really keen on finding a bed that stays really cool throughout the night. The coils in a hybrid mattress allow for loads of airflow throughout the middle of the bed.
However, all-foam mattresses like the Cocoon and Purple, can also sleep rather cool depending on what materials they use. Cocoon’s main attempt at sleeping cool is with it’s Chill cover. This cover uses phase change technology to pull heat away from the body. However, we found that the memory foam still has a tendency to heat up throughout the night.
The Purple on the other hand has it’s handy dandy polymer grid. This grid helps add a layer of air between you and the top layer of foam in the mattress. This layer of air helps keep the matter from heating up to begin with. As you move the heat escapes from the bed, allowing you to stay cool without your body heat getting absorbed and trapped in by the polyurethane transitional foam below. It is the grid and breathable cover that gives the Purple mattress the win in the Sleeping Cool category.
If sleeping cool is a concern to you make sure you check out our Best Mattresses for Hot Sleepers.
Whenever we look at edge support, we like to focus on how the mattress performance when we lay right up to the edge of the mattress. We find that foam mattresses don’t typically perform as well in this category as hybrid beds do. This is because coil systems provide extra support around the edges and can even be reinforced. Some foam beds reinforce they edges now as well.
The Purple and Cocoon mattresses do not have any fancy reinforcements around the perimeter of the mattress so Edge Support all comes down the materials they use. If you are hoping for lots of edge support, we would not suggest looking into the Purple mattress. We found that the Purple Grid’s design for pressure relief allows for column buckling. This same column buckling is what causes a slight rolling out feel if you lay too close to the edge of the Purple mattress.
The Cocoon performs slightly better in this category, as their base foam is highly supportive. You will notice an especially large difference in edge support with their Medium-Soft to their Extra-Firm comfort option. The firm comfort feel will provide much more edge support than the softer option. Which is why we give the Cocoon by Sealy the win for Edge Support, especially if you choose their Extra-Firm version.
The true value of a mattress is dependent on the quality of the mattress you’re getting matched with the given price. If we consider a mattress to be well priced for it’s quality then we rate it as having good value. When comparing to mattresses, we compare their quality and see how their prices match up.
With the Purple and Cocoon mattresses their overall quality is rather similar however for a few reasons, we would recommend the Cocoon. This is due to it’s performance with edge support, motion transfer, and multiple comfort options. All of this paired with it’s lower price point (before coupons even hit) make it definitely the mattress with more value.
Interested in the Purple Mattress? Learn more and shop at Purple.com.
You can save even more with a 25% OFF coupon using our code: OSG25. Your Cocoon purchase will include free shipping. You also get a 100-night sleep trial period to make sure it’s the best mattress for you. A 10-year warranty comes standard with the Cocoon mattress.
Interested in the Cocoon Classic or the Cocoon Chill? Learn more and shop at Cocoonbysealy.com.
With such a similar design and price point, it is no wonder why you may be trying to choose between these two mattresses. However, they do feel rather different. They Purple mattress has it’s unique grid topper that is great for keeping cool and pressure relief. While the Cocoon mattress by Sealy has that classic memory foam feel and comes in two different comfort options. The overall feel of these two mattresses when you lay on them is so different that the feel comes down to personal preference for the most part.
However, when we put these two beds to the test, we found that the Cocoon mattress out performed the Purple bed. If you are looking to buy one of these well priced beds, be sure to click the link and use our coupons to get the latest and greatest deals.
For more comparison reviews beyond the Cocoon vs Purple mattresses, make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This will give you access to all our comparison reviews. Including some of our most popular including the Puffy vs Purple, Casper vs Tuft & Needle, Casper vs Cocoon and Puffy vs Puffy Lux.
Or to make your own comparison selections use our Mattress Comparison Tool for a quick side by side glance at up to four of any of our mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.