Please note, we are proudly supported by our readers. The product links are referral based and if you purchase an item we make a small commission. For more information please see our disclosure page.
The best part about the end of the day should be your mattress. We spend more than one-third of our lives sleeping, so make it a great experience. If you haven’t updated your mattress recently, this could be negatively impacting your quality of sleep. Fortunately in today’s modern era, a new mattress can be yours with the simple click of a button. Online mattress shopping makes it simple. But when it comes to the Tuft and Needle Mint vs Casper it may be more difficult. Keep reading to see which one of these online bed-in-a-box mattresses is for you.
Tuft and Needle has found their niche market. By offering a high-quality mattress at an affordable price point. The Tuft and Needle Mint specifically is an upgraded model to the original Tuft and Needle, giving you now 12” of pure comfort.
Another ideal bed is the Casper mattress. Their famous claim is “one perfect mattress for everyone”. This is also a 12” mattress that offers 4 layers of comfort that you’re sure to have sweet dreams about. Continue reading for a comprehensive and unbiased mattress review of the Tuft and Needle Mint and Casper mattresses.
The Tuft and Needle Mint mattress is the epitome of out with the old and in with the new. Tuft and Needle knows that the way to remain in the mattress game is with the ability to adapt. The Tuft and Needle Mint mattress addresses some of the problems of its earlier, original mattress, to better your sleep even more. The Tuft and Needle mint is more durable and resilient to moisture.
The mattress is now I total of 12”, versus the original 10.5”. It uses three layers instead of the previous two of the classic Tuft and Needle, appealing to more types of sleepers. While you may have to adjust to this new mattress, especially if you are a Tuft and Needle fan, you will find even more benefits than the mattress before it.
Interested in learning more about the 12″ T&N model? Read our full Tuft and Needle Mint Review.
Casper Mattress Overview:
The Casper is meant to be “perfect for everyone”, but while it does offer some incredible benefits, keep in mind that some might object. The 12” thick all foam mattress comes with 4 layers of comfort for the perfect medium- firm feel. This means the Casper mattress will be just what you need for any sleeping position and any size sleeper. You’ll get a top layer that is more responsive and mimics latex, plus a more conforming memory foam layer than you’ll see in any other mattress.
This combo makes the Casper easy to move on, while still being pressure relieving. The Casper is also highly durable and supportive, wrapped for you like a present in a crisp, clean cover. As one of the first Online mattress companies, Casper knows customer service. So, returns are free and easy, shipping is free and fast, and you get a 100-night sleep trial, plus 10- year warranty.
Want to jump right to the full review? Find the Casper HERE!
Delivery and off-gassing should be the best and easiest part about purchasing an online mattress. The Tuft and Needle Mint mattress offers a specifically easy process. After you order the mattress online, it will be shipped to your home for free, within 1 to 3 weeks. Once it arrives, it will be in a relatively small box for a mattress, so you should be able to maneuver it on your own. Simply take the mattress to the room it needs to be in, remove the box, carefully cut away the plastic, and watch the magic happen before your eyes.
Your Tuft and Needle Mint mattress will expand almost immediately, and although it may look comfy and ready, it is recommended to wait at least 12 hours before use. This also allows for any leftover plastic and ‘new mattress’ smells to dissipate. If you are particularly sensitive to smells, be sure to open a window to help the off-gassing process.
Similarly, the Casper mattress will arrive at your door simple and stress-free. The fairly compact box weighs approximately 85 lbs., which means you may need some help maneuvering it. With a little help, bring the mattress where it needs to be. Open the box, carefully cut away the plastic, and watch your mattress expand like magic.
Like with most mattresses in a box, the Casper might have a “new smell” once it has unrolled and taken shape. These fumes are not harmful, but if you are sensitive to smells, it is wise to wait at least 12 to 24 hours to let your mattress off-gas the fumes and firm up to its full comfort.
With three layers, the Tuft and Needle Mint really takes a stand at improving the quality of the mattress. The first layer is the same T&N proprietary foam, only its an enhanced version. The 3” layer uses poly foam that is pressure relieving and also comfortable. It is also contouring, yet supportive, which means the more weigh that is applied to the foam, the more it pushes back. With extra graphite than the original Tuft and Needle, this layer pulls even more heat away from he body, keeping you nice and cool.
Next is the T&N adaptive foam transition layer; perhaps the one thing that was critically missing from the original Tuft and Needle. This 2” layer is everything to set the Tuft and Needle Mint apart from the Tuft and Needle. The layer uses 30% more gel beads than the original, which enhances its support and cushion. All this added gel not only keeps you cooler, but amplifiers the comfort of the mattress.
Lastly, is a similar 7’ T&N foam base layer. This layer is made of high density poly foam and surrounded by an additional foam encasement to enhance edge support and overall performance. This makes the base layer even thicker and therefore more reliable, while also increasing edge support. The entire mattress is wrapped in a soft, knit cover that made of polyester and viscose. This quick drying surface also keep you cooler at night and is one of the most durable fabrics on the market.
You can’t go wrong with 12” and 4 layers of pure comfort. The top layer is the breathable comfort layer. This layer is resilient, but has a good bounce to be able to return back to its original shape. The key to this layer is that it is soft without sinking in, and has great breathability to reduce heating. This top layer is in fact new to the Casper mattress and has replaced the original Dunlop layer, therefore decreasing the price.
The next layer is made of memory foam. This is just the kind of density you want in a memory foam, that contours to the sleeper’s body, while reliving pressure points to reduce tossing and turning. Beneath that is a layer of transitional poly foam. This is just the layer you need for comfort that is deeper than the surface, and distributes your weight evenly. This foam does exactly what it supposed to do, and provides a great transition from the comfort layers to the base foam.
The base foam is made of density poly foam. This layer is solid and durable, which means your mattress should never bottom out. It also provides the stability needed for all the other layers to do their job. You’ll also get more comfort from the Casper’s premium, woven polyester cover. The cover is tight to the mattress, soft to the touch, it still durable. The gray and white color is simple and aesthetically pleasing, so that you’ll love your new mattress top to bottom.
Everything that the Tuft and Needle Mint has in its materials, it also has in comfort. The Tuft and Needle Mint is still a universal mattress with a medium-firm or luxury firm feel. The mattress measures a 6 to 6.5 on a firmness scale of 1 to 10; 10 being the firmest.
This firmness level is meant to appeal to all types of sleepers, giving that extra softness that the original Tuft and Needle was missing, to allow side sleepers to sink in just a bit. Back sleepers will enjoy that the mattress does not sink in too far, and still gives the right amount of push back. The Tuft and Needle Mint is guaranteed to still maintain that ideal spinal alignment.
For stomach sleepers, the Tuft and Needle Mint does not allow their back to bow, and the adaptive foams provide even more variety and comfort; no more sleeping on just the base foam. Heavier sleepers will enjoy the Tuft and Needle Mint over the Tuft and Needle, since the thicker foams will create a more solid mattress, however Tuft and Needle mattresses are poly foam, whereas larger person should consider an all foam mattress.
The Casper is the only “one size fits all” mattress that you’ll want to sleep on. It has a universal medium to medium-firm feel, approximately a 6 to 6.5 on the firmness scale; 10 being the firmest, and 1 being the softest. The Casper is as universal as it claims. The mattress has great lumbar support for back sleepers, plus ideal contour for the shoulders and neck.
If you are predominately a stomach sleeper, rest assured the Casper is firm enough, not to create any bowing of your back. Finally, for side sleepers, the Casper would suffice, but could be too firm for a person who likes their shoulders and hips to sink in a little. For heavier stomach sleepers, this mattress might not be firm enough, so you may prefer to sleep on your side or back. If you’re new to buying a mattress online, the Casper is a safe and highly comfortable choice.
When you upgrade to the Tuft and Needle Mint, motion transfer might be slightly more in your favor. The thick layers of the Tuft and Needle Mint are slightly responsive, but thick enough to deaden any movement before it disturbs your sleep. Since the top layers sit atop a dense base layer, the base layer should easily absorb any excess movement, keeping the motion transfer to a minimum.
If you are more sensitive to movements, a light sleeper, or have a partner that tosses and turns, the Tuft and Needle Mint is a reliable choice. Similarly, the Casper was observed to have minimal motion transfer, allowing partners to sleep peacefully. This makes the mattress ideal for partners with different sleep schedules, or those that change positions often. However motion transfer is slightly better in the Tuft and Needle Mint.
Tuft and Needle Mint has a few more features to keep you cool. First, the added graphite keeps you cooler directly on top. The. The ceramic gel beads in the transition layer, make this layer very cool. Finally, the cover on the Tuft and Needle Mint is soft and breathable, keeping you cool immediately to the touch.
On the very top, the woven, stretch-knit cover on the Casper is more breathable. It also helps dissipate heat away from the body. This is helpful since it is the first layer your body touches. In addition, since the Casper is slightly firmer. It keeps you sleeping on top of the mattress, keeping you cooler, and increasing circulation. Finally, the Casper also has an open- top cell layer which helps pull bear away from the body and acts as a barrier from the memory foam.
With most foam mattresses, edge support will not be one of its strong suites. The Tuft and Needle Mint however was specifically designed to combat some of these faults, including edge support. The foam encasement that surrounds the Tuft and Needle Mint is one of a kind. Combing that with its solid base foam and you get better than most edge support. With the Tuft and Needle Mint, you get more edge support allowing you to utilize more of the mattress, and maybe even sleep near the edge without falling off.
Although the Casper attempts to address edge support effectively, it pales in comparison to an innerspring mattress and even other foam mattresses. It is likely that that you will be able to utilize the entire surface for sleeping on the Casper mattress. But sitting on the edge for more than just putting your socks on won’t be possible.
The Tuft and Needle Mint remains true to its affordable promise. The Tuft and Needle Mint starts at $595 for a Twin and up to $1145 for a king size.
The Casper, although a lesser quality mattress is $995 for a queen size.
The Tuft and Needle Mint is the upgraded version to the original. While the Casper has merely increased its prices for the same mattress. It’s clear that the Tuft and Needle mattress gives you better bang for your buck.
The Tuft and Needle Mint comes with a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty. Similarly, the Casper mattress offers the same 100-night trial and 10-year warranty. With the trial period, if you don’t love your mattress as much as they hope, you can return it for free and risk free.
Everyone loves upgrades, which means everyone loves the Tuft and Needle Mint. When it comes down to it, the Tuft and Needle Mint is the better choice when faced against the Casper and the best way to get the mattress brand you love, without sacrificing your sleep. The Tuft and Needle Mint includes three layers instead of two appealing to more types of sleepers.
The upgrades, such as foam encasement make your experience with sleeping cool, edge support, and motion transfer that much better. If you’re in the market for a new mattress, the choice is clear, Tuft and Needle Mint is the mattress for you.
For more comparisons reviews beyond the Tuft and Needle Mint vs Casper, make sure you check out our Mattress Comparison Page. This accesses all our comparison reviews, including Puffy vs Purple, Puffy vs Capser, Nectar vs Tuft and Needle, and Nolah vs Casper.
Also, check out our Mattress Comparison Tool for a quick side by side glance at up to four mattresses at once. This is a great way to help narrow down your top contenders and see the differences of each.
Not sure where to start? No problem! Let us help you start your mattress search with Our Mattress Guide to take out any confusion.
Also, have questions for us? Feel free to contact us!